‘Has millennials’ surge ended in LA and what happens next?’ Myers asks
By Matthew Kredell
A surge of millennials in Los Angeles County over the past decade revitalized neglected areas and invigorated the urban economy, while also flooding the rental housing market and pushing out working-class Angelenos. Professor Dowell Myers explained what’s next for millennials – many of whom now in their 30s – and what it means for their changing demands on the housing market, during a recent discussion at the USC Price School of Public Policy.
Myers’ Sept. 13 talk – “Has the Surge of Millennials Ended in LA and What Happens Next?” – was part of USC Urban Growth Seminar. The event series exposes graduate students to top scholars and professionals in the planning field for a discussion of innovative responses to complex urban problems. USC Assistant Professor of Sociology Ann Owens served as the discussant.
Millennials’ ‘raw deal’ as homebuyers
Presenting some of his latest research published in Cityscape and Housing Policy Debate, Myers noted that the millennial generation, comprised of 83 million people born between 1980 and 1999, is larger than the Baby Boomer generation. Millennials, Myers noted, are more willing to give up their car, more attracted to living in a dense city center, and much more present within two miles of the city center in downtown Los Angeles.
From his article “Peak Millennials,” Myers explained the reinforcing cycles that drive concentration of millennials in urban districts. The Great Recession stopped employment growth and the construction of new apartment complexes. Typically, people tend to progress up the economic ladder from renting to buying homes; however, in this case, would-be homeowners became renters, with millennials coming of age and existing renters sandwiched between diverted homeowners.
“Poverty and unemployment may have recovered from the Great Recession, but the housing shortages are long-lived and the millennials’ needs will keep expanding their impacts,” Myers said. “Will they be accommodated by new housing or will they keep scavenging old housing from other Angelenos?”
Between 2006 and 2014 in Los Angeles County, 314,000 would-be homeowners were diverted into rentals. Along with the expected 212,000 growth in renters from the millennial surge, this created a total potential growth in renters to 526,000, compared to a 177,000 increase in renter units — leaving 353,000 displaced renters.
“The worst thing is millennials have a bad economic environment, and they get really high housing prices too,” Myers said. “That’s not fair. I always thought when the Great Recession happened that the good news was that housing would be affordable. It didn’t work out that way, and that’s the raw deal.”
High income inequality
Owens pointed out that millennials are delaying marriage and child bearing, which may impact the type and location of housing they prefer, keeping them in cities longer.
Owens also presented her research on inequality among millennials. Although this is the most ethnically diverse adult generation, she noted that the attitudes about race aren’t that much different from older generations, and income inequality is higher among millennials than older generations.
“Millennials are not the post-racial society we pretended they were briefly, and racial segregation remains high among them,” Owens said. “It could be that millennials are the inequality generation, and we know that income inequality maps onto income segregation because it determines who can live where.”
Myers projected that there is an interesting intersection coming, as the millennials progress while aging Baby Boomers start selling off their homes.
“I like the way Professor Myers always makes things very clear, straightforward and easy for everybody to understand,” said Johanna Thunell, a Ph.D. student in Public Policy and Management. “He touched on the symbiosis between types of homeowners, how Boomers are going to be selling off their homes and people waiting to be homeowners might start buying.”